Campaigns and Discounts: The Hidden Cost of Markdowns
A discount management guide: margin impact, cannibalisation, alternatives to discounting, targeted campaigns and post-campaign measurement.
Discounting works — that is not the problem. The problem is that because it works, it gets repeated without being measured. A brand that discounts three months running finds its customers waiting for a discount in the fourth; and from that point the normal price looks expensive.
The margin maths is harsher than it looks
A 20% discount does not cost 20% of revenue but a much larger share of profit. A simple example: a 100 sale, 60 cost, 40 profit. At 20% off, the sale becomes 80, the cost stays the same, and profit falls to 20 — meaning a 20% price cut is a 50% profit cut.
So the first calculation is: by what multiple must sales grow to make up the lost profit? In the example above, it must double. If the campaign does not deliver that, the business has sold more and earned less.
Three hidden costs
Cannibalisation
The discount is used by customers who would have paid full price anyway. A discount that brings no new customers is a direct loss of profit.
Reference price shift
Customers learn the discounted price as “the real price”. When the campaign ends, sales fall below normal and take time to recover.
Training expectations
Customers of a brand that discounts regularly learn to wait. Adding to a basket and waiting for a markdown is a habit you created.
Alternatives worth trying
- Free shipping: high perceived value, usually cheaper than a discount. It is also the most common cause of abandoned baskets.
- A gift or sample: costs you production price and is perceived at retail price. The margin impact is far softer.
- Bundles: raise basket value; the discount applies to a set rather than a single product.
- Extended returns or warranty: low cost, and it lowers purchase risk.
- Early access: a privilege for loyal customers at no cost at all.
- Loyalty points: defer the discount to a future purchase and encourage repeat buying.
Targeted beats broad
When a discount goes to everyone, cannibalisation is at its maximum. Segment-based design reduces it:
- Champions get no discount — they are already buying; they get privileges and early access.
- At-risk customers justify a win-back incentive; on a customer you would otherwise lose, a discount is an investment.
- New customers get an incentive aimed at the second order, not the first.
- Dormant customers get one strong attempt; if there is no reply, stop.
Measuring after the campaign
The only number usually checked afterwards is revenue — and it misleads. What to look at:
- Gross profit, not revenue. A campaign that raised revenue and lowered profit failed.
- Share of new customers: how much of the sales came from new buyers? That is the measure of cannibalisation.
- The week after: did sales return to normal or fall below it? The latter means you pulled demand forward.
- Return rate: usually higher on discounted sales, and it should be deducted from the net effect.
- Repurchase by campaign buyers: customers who only buy on discount produce little long-term value.
Frequently asked questions
A competitor is discounting — do I have to?
Price is the easiest thing to copy and the hardest to win on. Differentiating on another axis (delivery speed, easy returns, service) is usually a more defensible position than matching the discount.
Do end-of-season sales fall under the same logic?
No; clearing stock is a different objective with different maths. The cost of remaining stock is already sunk, so the question is not “how much profit” but “how much recovery”.
How do I track who used a discount code?
Code-level tracking is the only way to measure a campaign’s real effect: how many used it, the average basket, how many were new customers. Without codes, before-and-after comparison is guesswork.
Next step: to see segment-based campaign design, request a demo.